I am a little bit sad that the #Fediverse largely cristallised in a way that made Mastodon-like microblogging the default, and everything else an 'extension' at best.
Of course there are other systems and software choices out there, but from what I can see, the only non-microblogging one with real staying power is Pixelfed.
I am a big fan of the 'personal macroblogging' style of social media, i. e. what Facebook and Myspace were back in the day. Specifically, a big focus on structured social data and the way software uses that to provide functionality automatically.
I want expansive profiles with tons of fields like hobbies, birthday and other anniversaries, fun fact and trivia, favourite bands, foods, songs, ideology, location, nicknames, game collections...
And I want the software to be able to use that data for cool functionality! I want birthday reminders for my friends, I wanna get profile recommendations for people with similar hobbies and tastes! I want to be able to create events and notify everyone who is into the same things! I want to be able to have hobby groups to post into and fanpages and all.
Over here on the microblogging side of things, profiles are pretty barebones and there's hardly any data integration. The only fields that software really considers is name, pronouns, hashtags and in some cases specific integrations like ListenBrainz on GoToSocial. That's it. Everything beyond that is just posts.
I get why collecting and sharing vast amounts of personal data kiiinda went out of fashion, but I think consent-based systems rather than data brokers would make me comfortable enough to share these things.
I know Friendica and Diaspora exist, but their development is super slow, they don't federate well, and more importantly, their communities are nonexistant. What use is the best technology in the world if nobody uses it? Noone uses Friendica events and birthdays and whatever. That makes me sad.
Matthias (feb)
in reply to lia, a bun type creature • • •@lia, a bun type creature
How did you arrive at this assessment? Friendica's development is extremely active. It is constantly being further developed and continues to deliver new features that are later adopted by the rest of the Fediverse.
I assume you were referring to Diaspora. Their users are simply very satisfied with what's available. Sometimes that's exactly the right amount.
Stage name Jay Peach
in reply to lia, a bun type creature • • •ARGVMI~1.PIF
in reply to lia, a bun type creature • • •lia, a bun type creature
in reply to ARGVMI~1.PIF • • •True, but the federation to the rest of ActivityPub is really lacklustre from what I could see.
Despite ActivityPub being a thing and fedi software technically being interoperable, does anyone actually regularly see content from, say, PeerTube, Friendica or Lemmy on their timeline? I don't really. It's all microblogging here.
Part of the problem is that many software choices just seem to treat inter-software federation as an afterthought.
PeerTube for example shows videos and video comments, sure, but how would I view a timeline of, let's say, recent Misskey posts from people I follow? Or a poll posted from a Friendica instance? PeerTube doesn't really support anything but videos and comments on videos, so I can't see any of that nor can I feasibly use it as my "main" Fediverse software for that reason.
Julian Dumitrascu
in reply to lia, a bun type creature • • •Online public talks · Issue #8 · Julian-Dumitrascu/communication
Julian-Dumitrascu (GitHub)Ivar Espås Vangen
in reply to lia, a bun type creature • •I am one of the few Norwegians that are active on Friendica, and I agree about some of your points. I miss the "idea" of Facebook, as it was back in 2008, or so.
But why do you think that Friendica does not federate well? For example, I can follow (and interact with) people on Bluesky from here. That is not possible on Mastodon, for instance.
I believe Friendica has potential, but now it lacks content more than anything. If there is more content and activity here, then I believe more developers will catch interest too.